Ducting and weaving: New standard ends confusion
A new ductwork standard is set to put a stop to confusion and reveal new opportunities for contractors, according to Andrew SteelClassify the risk
The introduction of a new British Standard for cleanliness levels in ductwork has been heralded as an opportunity to end confusion within the industry. BS EN 15780:2011 Ventilation for buildings - Ductwork - Cleanliness of ventilation systems clearly defines vital goals to be achieved by anyone responsible for maintaining ventilation systems by recognising that different room uses require different standards and that newly installed ductwork should be handed over in a clean condition.
The new standard has been in force since April and defines cleanliness criteria, recognising that absolute cleanliness cannot be achieved but that a degree of objectivity is needed in assessment. You can be sure ventilation ductwork inspected and maintained according to the new British Standard is really clean according to objective test and measurement results.
Standardised levels of cleanliness in ductwork systems laid out according to a building's intended use. Ventilation system specifiers, installers and facilities managers now have clear guidance, a published set of standards and clear criteria that can apply to all building ventilation ductwork.
Defines assessment criteria
This standard applies to both new and existing ventilation and air conditioning systems and defines the assessment criteria of cleanliness, cleaning procedures of these systems, and the validation of the effectiveness of cleaning. It also applies to products used in air conditioning and ventilation systems for human occupancy. Although the standard doesn't apply to installations for industrial processes, it does apply to other areas of the building such as office areas.
There may be many in the HVAC industry who say they weren't confused in the first place and TR/19 has served us well, so why change at all?
The bottom line is that the UK really had no choice but to introduce this British Standard as our national implementation of EN15780: 2011. The membership of CEN, the European Committee for Standardisation, comprises the National Standards Bodies (NSBs) of the 27 European Union countries, Croatia, The Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, and Turkey plus three countries of the European Free Trade Association (Iceland, Norway and Switzerland).
In other words, there is a vast reservoir of experience that has gone into creating the new standard and accusations of 'Euro-bureaucracy gone mad' would be very wide of the mark! It is, in any case, expected that TR/19 will be brought into line with the new British Standard.
Consequently a positive way to welcome the new standard would be to grasp the opportunity to take a fresh view of your installed systems. After all, BS EN15780:2011 comes at a time when businesses are looking at the carbon footprint of every item of equipment they operate and looking for ways to find savings, so re-examination of cleaning and maintenance regimes is on the agenda anyway. There is not so very much to distinguish the new standard from the familiar HVAC TR/19 and, indeed, both can only offer guidance, not mandatory standards, so compliance with the new standard does not require big changes to be made.
At Airmec, we see the new standard as a positive development that makes us all look again at familiar practices and assumptions. It ensures that we are all aware of, and in agreement on, what is good practice in cleaning and maintenance and how to measure its effectiveness. And as the often quoted saying goes, if you can't measure it, you can't manage it.
We often see systems that, according to the log book, have been regularly cleaned but which, by professional standards fall well short of acceptable, safe and efficient good practice. Many users' philosophy, which was typically set up with a safety brief only, has not been reviewed for years and does not consider energy efficiency or equipment service life as objectives. The new Standard gives us all a benchmark and can be an eye opener for building managers.
The British Standard also cross references with other standards that apply to HVAC systems such as BS EN 12599:2000 which defines test procedures and measuring methods for new systems. Finding a way around the standards maze will ever be easy, but this new standard definitely appears to be a step in the right direction, and should help managers to understand their obligations and help them manage their overall running costs.
The ultimate goal for facilities professionals is to design and build a system enabling good standards of cleanliness to be maintained throughout the life of the equipment easily and inexpensively. The new standard does set out precisely what the level of cleanliness should be when a new system is handed over, depending on the type of building and level of risk its use indicates.
Increasing service life
However, while much of the publicity around BS EN 15780 has focused on its guidance on new ductwork it also applies to existing ventilation and air conditioning systems. Application of the new standard can also serve to increase the service life of expensive ventilation equipment - a concept that proves popular in any boardroom these days.
The new standard clearly defines cleanliness values for existing ductwork depending on application. As an example dust levels should be <3.0g/sq m in a medium risk building (4.5g/sq m for re-circulation and secondary ductwork). Medium risk areas cover offices, hotels, restaurants, schools and the like. A typical low risk area would be a low-occupancy storeroom and high risk would be, say, treatment areas of hospitals.
This is not the place to go into much more the detail on the new standard, but the key point to remember is that BS EN 15780:2011 Ventilation for buildings - Ductwork - Cleanliness of ventilation systems clearly defines, for the first time, what is considered acceptably clean in ductwork and differentiates pragmatically between different types of building use to define low, medium and high risks. This enables building managers to plan appropriate and proportionate cleaning and inspection regimes. By using this standard, facilities professionals can unambiguously:
Assess the need for cleaning
Assess the frequency of cleaning that is required
Decide what method of cleaning to adopt
Measure objectively the effectiveness of cleaning and adjust their regime as necessary
At Airmec we have trained all of our technicians and consultants to undertake inspections that both comply with the new standard and also seek to emphasise that duct cleanliness is not just purely a safety issue. An appropriate duct cleanliness maintenance regime can also provide significant contributions to energy efficiency. Consequently, as utility prices continue to rise and the penalties to businesses for wasting energy increase an effective cleaning and maintenance regime can deliver a meaningful return on investment.
In summary, both the duty of care and business imperative to clean and maintain systems is just the same, but now there is virtually no room for doubt over the regimes that need to be in place. Doing too little is potentially dangerous and leads to inefficiencies, doing too much means paying too much. This new standard really does help you to judge and quantify what really is best for your building and occupants.
// The author is managing director of Airmec //
1 October 2012